Cuffe Parade blaze a fire alarm for Mumbai

Fire Brigade's Ladders Reach Up To Only 68 Metres. In June, 78 Proposals For 70-Metre-Plus Buildings Were Cleared

    Sunday's fire at the residential Jolly Maker-1 tower in Cuffe Parade exposed how ill-prepared Mumbai is to fight highrise blazes on two counts. First, the fire brigade is too poorly equipped to respond to emergencies on higher floors. Second, despite the tony, 26-storey building having an internal fire-fighting system, it turned out to be useless as it was not kept in functioning condition. Shockingly, residents said the building had recently installed the fire-fighting system. 
    It is important to fight fires from within the building as also from without, but Mumbai appears to be not up to the challenge even as the high-rise committee -- which has a fire officer on board -- continues clearing proposals for even taller buildings. 
    While the fire brigade has ladders that reach up to only 68 metres (20 to 25 storeys), there are around 1,200 buildings taller than 70 metres in the city. In June this year, Retired Justice Shafi Parkar, the high-rise committee chairman, and municipal commissioner Sitaram Kunte cleared development proposals for 78 skyscrapers taller than 70 metres. Parkar said the fire brigade's preparedness is taken into account when clearing a proposal for a skyscraper. However, it took fire-fighters four hours to fight Sunday's blaze, which was on the 19th floor. 
    The BMC will soon be spending Rs 15 crore to obtain advanced aerial ladders that can reach up to 90 metres (around 30 storeys). When Suhas Joshi, Mumbai's chief fire officer, was asked how fires would be handled in buildings of 30 or more storeys, he said, "Under such circumstances, firefighters depend heavily on internal systems installed by the developers so they can fight the fire from the inside." However, as the Jolly Maker-1 blaze showed, internal systems are not inspected often enough. 
    According to the BMC's estimate, there are over 5,000 highrises (buildings taller than seven storeys) in Mumbai and the number keeps increasing. 
    Despite a senior fire official telling TOI that the fire brigade is equipped to handle fires as high as 68 metres, fire-fighters were in September seen struggling with hydraulic ladders that refused to reach even the 12th floor at BKC. A fire had raged for two hours at the First International Financial Centre (FIFC) building. After some trial-and-error tactics, three hydraulic ladders with different heights were used to reach the 12th floor. In June, the fire brigade took over 12 hours to douse a raging inferno that spread through the upper floors of the state secretariat, Mantralaya. 
    "One can't object to high-rises, per se," said city-based architect P K Das, member, Indian Institute of Architects. "But the fact is that we, as a city, are ill-equipped and incapable of dealing with emergencies in high-rises. Our infrastructure is also not designed to handle high-rises. Having isolated high-rises in parts of the city proves counter-productive. There has to be a larger vision for Mumbai. When the state's high-rise committee approves proposals for skyscrapers, it must look at the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation's preparedness, infrastructure and the carrying capacity of the areas in which the buildings are proposed. There should be a comprehensive study and not one based on an individual plot or building." 
COLABA PROBE YET TO FINISH 
    Aday after a major fire broke out on the 19th floor of Jolly Maker-1, a Cuffe Parade residential tower, the fire brigade was yet to conclude its investigation and ascertain the cause of the blaze. Fire brigade officers said they are in the process of giving the society's management a notice for the defunct fire-fighting system in the building. The nonfunctioning equipment delayed getting the blaze under control. Senior fire brigade officials said the most likely cause of the blaze would be a short-circuit in the AC unit of the house on the 19th floor. On Monday, residents were returning to their homes, which they had left following the fire early on Sunday morning. TNN 
WHAT THE FIRE DEPARTMENT HAS 
20 aerial ladders, some reaching up to 68m, others up to 42m Advanced rescue tenders Advanced water tankers with high pressure jets Advanced pumps Turntable ladders Hydraulic platforms 
WHAT THE DEPT NEEDS 
Hydraulic ladders reaching up to 90m (under process) Adequate staff, including firemen Special cell to inspect high-rises, malls, multiplexes and commercial complexes (to be ready by next year) 
Most importantly, fire-fighting needs to be done from within, with fire-safety engineering done during construction. A high-rise can have fire-fighter & safety lifts, protective lobbies, refuge areas, emergency power and water, emergency lights at exits and direct exits

BURNING ISSUE: It took the fire brigade four hours to battle a blaze on the 19th floor of the 26-storey Jolly Maker-1, thanks to poor equipment and a non-functioning fire-safety system in the building

PETRONAS TOWERS 
(KUALA LUMPUR, MALAYSIA) IN-BUILT SAFETY 
Fire-fighting shafts with elevators 
There is an In-built Building Control System (BCS) for central management of power and ACs, which is linked to a life-safety system activated during emergencies. If a fire breaks out on a floor, the BCS provides for a pressure differential between that and other floors to contain the flare-up 
A 190-foot-long sky-bridge connects both towers on the 41st and 42nd floors, ensuring that people can cross over to the other tower in case one catches fire 
Regular fire drills with evacuation pegged at 20 minutes

BURJ KHALIFA 
(DUBAI) IN-BUILT SAFETY 
Fire-fighters' elevator with a capacity of 5,500 kg allows firefighters to transport equipment. Some other elevators are also programmed for controlled evacuation with emergency power 
Pressurized air-conditioned refuge areas every 25 floors and fire-proof stairways 
LCD panels display emergency updates specific to each floor 
Multi-alarm sensors with smoke, heat and optical sensors are present on each floor

2 killed in Kamala Mills bldg crash

Mumbai: Two floors of the three-storeyed Victoria House at Kamala Mills Compound in Lower Parel that houses offices of the Jindal Group caved in during the busy morning hours on Monday, crushing two persons to death and injuring six. All the casualties are Jindal employees. 
    Civic officials suspect major portions of the floors collapsed due to unauthorized renovation on the ground floor that affected the structure of the century-old building. The walls and the outer shell of Victoria House are intact. 
    Amruta Shukla (29) and Manoj Shukla (44), who were working on the first floor, were killed once the second floor fell on them. Six others were rescued, but the two were declared dead on arrival in hospital. Amrita was employed with the group's Pen office and had come to complete some paper work at the Pandurang Budhkar Marg office. JSW, others booked for collapse deaths 
Renovation Not Ours: Jindal Steel 
Mumbai: Police have booked two contractors, JSW Steel and another company for negligence after two floors of the three-storey Victoria House in Lower Parel collapsed on Monday, killing two Jindal employees. They have been booked under several IPC sections dealing with death caused by negligence for sending workers into the building despite knowing that it was unsafe, said N M Joshi Marg senior inspector Sudhakar Ghagare. 
    Internal repair/alteration works had been going on in the building for the last few days. Huge cracks were noticed in the portion that collapsed a few days ago and the employees who were occupying that place had relocated to other parts of the office, said some eyewitnesses. 
    "There were cracks in the building and we had marked some portion near the walls as dangerous. We had even instructed our employees not to enter that area. In the morning, some sound and dust started coming from the walls. As we were asking employees to move out, the entire floor fell down," said Pushkaraj Kole from JSW Steel. 
    The ground-plus-two-storey Victoria House constructed in 1897 was acquired by JSW Steel in 2005. The company converted part of it into their offices and had been leasing out the other sections. Incidentally, the building housed a media office backed by the Zee group till they moved about two months ago. 
    JSW Steel has said the renovation work on the ground floor was not being carried out by them. "This event appeared to have happened due to certain modifications being done in the ground floor which does not belong to the JSW Group," said the steelmaker in a statement. 
    The group has offices on the first and second floors and a small reception area on the ground floor. A major part of the second floor came crashing down between 11 and 11.10am, trapping several people under the debris. Within a few seconds, the first floor caved in under the weight of the second floor. 
    There were over 50 people in the building when the incident occurred, but most of them managed to run out as soon as the second floor caved in. Six persons — Hiral Dave (35), Aniruddha Patil (37), Prakash Nambi (34), Rajiv Jain (46), Santan Paniker (60) and Suraj Dhandaniya (41) — were injured and pulled out from under debris by the fire brigade. Three suffered fractures and one a head injury. Acting dean of KEM Hospital Dr Preeti Mehta said the patients are stable. 
    KEM Hospital sources said the two deceased — Amruta Shukla and Manoj Shukla (not related) — had suffered multiple injuries. Khargar resident Manoj, who worked in the company's sales tax department, was apparently busy discussing work when the floors collapsed. He is survived by his wife and two children. 
    The rescue operations went on for over four hours as the fire brigade faced problems due to lack of space. "We have cleared the debris. The office had steel furniture and many metal frames. We had to use metal cutters to remove the debris," said a fire official. 
    For two hours after the collapse, traffic police closed the adjoining south-bound carriageway of Pandurang Budhkar Marg for rescue operations. The lane was made available to motorists by 2 pm on Monday. 
GOING DOWN 
    Around 11am, a major portion of the 2nd floor of the three-storey Victoria House caves in on the first floor (above), trapping at least 8 people. Two die, six rescued 
    Around 30 people are on the 2nd floor at that time, most of them manage to run out 
    In a few seconds, a large part of the first floor collapses under the weight of the debris. There are over 20 people on the floor who flee unhurt

The walls of Victoria House in Lower Parel stand intact after the cave-in